You are watching: Is montresor a reliable or unreliable narrator
there is sufficient evidence to indicate that Montresor is absolutely an unreliable narrator in Poe"s classic brief story "The Cask of Amontillado ." In the opening paragraph the the short story, Montresor says that Fortunato had caused the a "thousand injuries" and "ventured ~ above insult," which apparently justify his...
Start your 48-hour free trial come unlock this answer and thousands more. Gain 6294.org ad-free and also cancel anytime.
There is sufficient evidence to imply that Montresor is definitely an unreliable narrator in Poe"s classic brief story "The Cask the Amontillado." In the opening paragraph the the quick story, Montresor claims that Fortunato had actually caused the a "thousand injuries" and also "ventured upon insult," which reportedly justify his motivation for seeking revenge. Montresor"s reason for committing a horrific killing is vague, obscure, and ambiguous. He gives no solid evidence to assistance his decision, which is unsettling and problematic. If one were to also contemplate burying an additional person alive, over there should absolutely be legitimate proof to also justify the assumed of acquisition that person"s life. However, Montresor just glosses over Fortunato"s "injuries" and also assumes that his actions are warranted.
In enhancement to Montresor"s vague reasoning for seek revenge ~ above Fortunato, the fact that Montresor commits murder is further evidence of his unreliability. One might argue that a sane, rational human would never bury another individual alive. Plotting and executing together a horrific crime argues a level of mental illness and also instability. Another example of Montresor"s unreliability takes location at the end of the story. Montresor thrusts his torch in the remaining aperture in the wall surface and lets it loss in really hopes of gaining a rise out that his enemy. However, Fortunato does no reply and also all Montresor deserve to hear is the jingling of bells. Montresor climate mentions,
"My heart grew sick—on account the the wet of the catacombs" (Poe, 10).
See more: Swiss Miss Hot Chocolate Expiration Date, Fresh Guide
This statement is further proof to imply that Montresor is an unreliable narrator. The audience recognizes the his heart "grew sick" together a an outcome of his guilty conscience and tortured soul. Somewhere in Montresor"s heart, he regrets his actions and pities his enemy. However, Montresor would have the reader believe that the dampness of the catacombs was the factor his heart grew sick, i m sorry is an noticeable lie. Overall, one might argue the Montresor is one unreliable narrator due to the fact that he refuses to give details reasons to justify his actions, commits a horrific crime, and attempts come conceal his true feelings concerning Fortunato"s murder.